| 01 | Phil Jagielka - Sheffield United |
| 02 | Steve Sidwell - Reading |
| 03 | Andrew Johnson - Crystal Palace |
| 04 | Lee Trundle - Swansea City |
| 05 | Dave Kitson - Reading |
| 06 | David Nugent - Preston North End |
| 07 | Ibrahima Sonko - Reading |
| 08 | Cameron Jerome - Cardiff City |
| 09 | Ade Akinbiyi - Sheffield United |
| 10 | Bobby Convey - Reading |
| 11 | Jolean Lescott - Wolverhampton Wanderers |
| 12 | Boaz Myhill - Hull City |
| 13 | Marlon King - Watford |
| 14 | Marcus Hahnemann - Reading |
| 15 | Kevin Doyle - Reading |
| 16 | Chris Morgan - Sheffield United |
| 17 | Glen Little - Reading |
| 18 | Tom Soares - Crystal Palace |
| 19 | Neill Danns - Colchester United |
| 20 | Danny Shittu - Queens Park Rangers |
| 21 | Paddy Kenny - Sheffield United |
| 22 | Ashley Young - Watford |
| 23 | Soel Ki-Hyeon - Wolverhampton Wanderers |
| 24 | Michael McIndoe - Doncaster Rovers |
| 25 | Nick Montgomery - Sheffield United |
| 26 | Nathan Tyson - Nottingham Forest |
| 27 | Kenny Miller - Wolverhampton Wanderers |
| 28 | Karl Hawley - Carlisle United |
| 29 | Grant Holt - Nottingham Forest |
| 30 | Billy Sharp - Scunthorpe United * |
| 31 | Leroy Lita - Reading |
| 32 | Greg Halford - Colchester United |
| 33 | Darren Ward - Crystal Palace |
| 34 | Sam Sodje - Brentford |
| 35 | Kevin Nicholls - Luton Town |
| 36 | Roger Johnson - Wycombe Wanderers |
| 37 | John McGreal - Burnley |
| 38 | Eddie Lewis - Leeds United |
| 39 | Brian Stock - Preston North End |
| 40 | Matthew Kilgallon - Leeds United |
| 41 | Darryl Flahavan - Southend United |
| 42 | Jay Tabb - Brentford |
| 43 | Nathan Clarke - Huddersfield Town |
| 44 | Matty Fryatt - Leicester City |
| 45 | Luke Guttridge - Southend United |
| 46 | Grant McCann - Cheltenham Town |
| 47 | Matthew Lockwood - Leyton Orient |
| 48 | Joe Hart - Shrewsbury Town |
| 49 | Chris Birchall - Port Vale |
| 50 | John McDermott - Grimsby Town |
* Former Sheffield United player